An amazing character in an amazing season of Star Trek! Now if they are responding with insults and and threats, ect. Captain Shaw tragically sacrificed his life in the penultimate episode of Picard season 3, allowing his friends to escape. . But it turns out episode nines biggest blow may not matter so much in the grand scheme of things, if Picard showrunner Terry Matalas gets his way. Huh? 2K CGI. Shaws alternate death scene. I dont think its offensive, but I do think its lame and arrogant if they block folks for politely bringing up minor critiques or questions, and I am not going to stop feeling that way. Star Trek: Picard may have taken its final bow back in April, but fans of the series are still eagerly awaiting the final season's home release including all of the bonus content that will inevitably accompany it. I hated that they offed Ro (apparently there was another version considered where she didnt die and was beamed away), but it was a long overdue story, just not enough arc. On the fandom end of things, the blocks do sting, especially when there doesnt seem to be a reason for it, but its still all low stakes hurt feelings any of us who have something truly important to say to Terry Matalas probably have his actual contact info. Trek is not and will never be what it once was. He displays this by addressing Seven of Nine as her birth name, Annika Hansen. Captain Shaw entered the USS Titan-A's holodeck recreation of 10 Forward and rudely interrupted Admiral Picard's bonding time with his son, Jack Crusher (Ed Speleers). Ralphie is right there !!! It was presumed that, if the show was commissioned, Shaw would be a big part of Matalas' proposed Star Trek: Legacy, however his heroic death in Star Trek: Picard season 3, episode 9, "Vox . Its his worst nightmare, but one he faces heroically, and he gets to be the one who sends them on the escape pod. Jaw-Dropping Surprise: Never-Before-Seen Alternative Death Scene of Captain Shaw Will Return If Star Trek: Legacy Happens Both Terry Matalas and actor Todd Stashwick have confirmed that Captain Liam Shaw will return in Star Trek: Legacy if the show is greenlit. but right on point: theyre the borg, they know who they are and they dont need to advertise! The Doctor back and they are serving on the Voyager A too. In horror, Riker and Picard watch the events unfold, as they realize they haven't been staring down a repeat of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine's Dominion War, but they're engaged in the high-stakes conclusion to a battle with the Borg that first began 30 years earlier. 3.Much Graver Threat. Troi learns the truth about Jack Crusher, the Changelings strike at Frontier Day, and an old enemy returns in Picard season 3's penultimate episode. :D. Too bad I didnt know about this yesterday, when I could have asked Stashwick which version he preferred. Are we in trouble again? To save the lives of their children, and the Federation itself, Admiral Jean-Luc Picard (Patrick Stewart), Dr. Beverly Crusher (Gates McFadden), and Commodore Geordi La Forge and the rest of their Star Trek: The Next Generation crewmates return to the Athan Prime Fleet Museum. Upscale. His death was ruled a suicide by the Arkansas State Crime Lab. You almost wonder whether they might try to retcon the death away. ENT, Star Trek: Legacy, Star Trek: Picard, TNG, CBS/Paramount, DVD/Blu-ray/Streaming, Feature Films (TMP-NEM), Kelvin Universe, Star Trek Universe TV, Trek on TV, DVD/Blu-ray/Streaming, Star Trek: Prodigy. With members of the Titan's crew looking on, Shaw finally unleashed his barely-concealed fury at Picard. And while fans (and the cast) have voiced their desire to see a spinoff show focused on Seven of Nine as the new captain of the next USS Enterprise, theres still no news yet whether that will happen. Following the end of the series executive producer Alex Kurtzman told Fox LA that they've "heard fans loud and clear.". In other words, Eagles dont flock my friend. The episode where they visit the museum? The first clip from Prodigys 2nd season premiere is up on startrek dot com! So the whole show we think its about this one Child, Jack. Its a wonderful tool. What even was the story on Picard? The series would, in theory, follow Captain Seven of Nine aboard the newly minted USS Enterprise-G, with her first officer Raffi (Michelle Hurd), and trusted advisor Jack Crusher (Speleers), at her side. No because we need to stop funding more Nu-Trek we need to starve it into hibernation until some better and more original writers come along. How? I get not liking Jack. I do hear you regarding that upscaling is not all that important, but nevertheless, native resolution 4K is ALWAYS better looking than a 2K upscale. Its the high dynamic range, or HDR10/Dolby Vision that really make UHD pop. Thats also the reason why the garden variety nitpicker Trekkie doesnt get hired for any Trek production. Star Trek: Picard Season 3 streams Thursdays on Paramount+. The enterprise D doesnt get put back into storage. His current focuses are on covering the Arrowverse, Star Trek: Discovery, and the DC Cinematic Universe. Permalink: Our only option. By your logic, nobody except the CEO of the corporation that produces something owes anything to me regarding their companys product, because the 20,000 employees who work for him just get paid by him. How is Shaw a captain? : r/startrekpicard - Reddit It was his way of finally showing her he believed she belonged in Starfleet. Some fans are dicks so sure block those idiots, but what Im seeing here is contempt for everyday normal fans and this is not acceptable. Thats all we are doing here, so whats your problem? Liam Shaw the blunt, outspoken captain of the U.S.S. My main point though was the certainly, when we hear about people getting blocked for seemingly minor critiques, we as fans certainly have the right to publicly comment on those blocks being unnecessarily vindictive. I just have like nearly 1000 BRs, so upgrading every disc I already have that comes out in 4K is not something I will automatically do until I am certain I will notice a substantial viewing experience improvement and I would say in about 50% of these cases, I do upgrade (and how fond I am of the movie actually factors in to my personal benefit-cost assessment on the upgrade as well). Now the one exception to this is if you or in a space that advertises that its there open to the public for everyone to freely express their opinion good bad or indifferent, and then block you because you post an opinion that differs then their own you could certainly state that they are acting in a hypocritical manner versus their stated goals for their public space. You can puke and pass out anytime without those disapproving stares. This weeks Star Trek: Picard set up big stakes for what will be the very last episode of the seriesand you cant have big stakes without some big threats and big blows for our heroes. No its not acceptable behavior. This explains why Changeling impersonators replaced transporter technicians like Ensign Foster (Chad Lindberg) as it gave them the access they needed to insert the code. I thought that was a righteous answer and still do. Only to kill them off for a few minutes additional dramatic effect. Star Trek's Captain Shaw During "Vx," Shaw, the commanding officer aboard the USS Titan-A, took a fatal phaser blast to save his The Next Generation cohorts. Can you see how I can support your opinion to complain about getting blocked, but also agree that all posters have the right to block others if they so wish. And should we be so lucky to ever have a discussion, it would be very cool, and Todd Stashwick would absolutely be a part of it.. Your favorite teams, topics, and players all on your favorite mobile devices. I think I prefer it. RELATED: Star Trek Picard's Jack Crusher Powers Explained. Terry Matalas shared a short video clip on his Twitter of Captain Shaw's final moments, with an extra line of dialogue. stunt double: Hana Lee Sakakibara (1 episode, 2022) . One of those was Todd Stashwicks Captain Liam Shaw. Like many 5 years ago, the film was taken from a 2K master and upconverted to Blu-ray. That was always his story.. I have no problem with posting on a different forum or social platform, about the circumstances of getting blocked somewhere else. According to TMZ, Captain Howard passed away in Florida at some point towards the end of October. And I think folks forget that writers and show runners have less control over the final product than we like to think. Star Trek: The Next Generation lit up his five year-old brain like a firework, ensuring hed be a progressive nerd for the rest of his life. Not really interested in percentages. Titan who was. Captain Shaw's death was an emotional moment in Season 3, and the alternate scene adds a comedic touch. Yes. Holy Bajoran, Batman! These arent elected officials taking away democratic right of recourse, theyre creatives drowning out whatever noise they dont want to tune in to. Sorry, but not everyone has a PhD on the finer points of the ***original series prime univorssssss***. But like most Starfleet officers in Admiral Picards inner circle, Shaw veered from his straight line to help prevent Starfleets demise. In addition to Sidney La Forge, other bridge crew like Lieutenant Matthew Arliss Mura (Joseph Lee) and Ensign Kova Rin Esmar (Jim Maley) seem like obvious additions. Now, likely in celebration of the fan convention Star Trek Las Vegas, Season 3 showrunner Terry Matalas has shared an alternate scene from the show's final episodes. Thats really interesting! For those upset about [SPOILERS] : r/Picard - Reddit To withdraw your consent, see Your Choices. The line does take away a bit from the moment when Shaw finally calls Seven by her preferred name, which may have been why it was cut. Star Trek Picard - Captain Shaw's death sceneSeason 3 Episode 9 - "Vox" So now it seems all Trek fans who grew to love the irascible, and now former, captain of the U.S.S. Its yours. I am glad we agree that this is a big deal, because certainly those VFX are going to appear soft, plus you will notice any issues more, with the upscaling. Unfortunately, not everyone made it out alive. And in his last moments, he gets to show Seven of Nine the respect that he always knew she was due. Not based on how they interact with the public, unless its so offensive that their employers would feel it would damage their business model. 2021 Viacom, International Inc. All Rights Reserved. But if it were a Trek movie? They are hired by others, paid by others. Some Hollywood types are lacking in that respect. Speaking to Collider in the wake of this weeks surprise decision to see Todd Stashwicks standout hero Captain Shaw sacrifice it all to save Picard and his friends from the Borg-Changeling alliance taking over Starfleet, Matalas discussed the inevitable end that Shaw faced after being introduced in this final season. Yep, and we are perfectly fine to call them out on Breaking this implied social contract with us fans despite what Mark Wood at Trekmovie tells uslol. This version has Shaw saying [Its not my ship] anymore. Fans will be pushing extra hard once it circulates more. The voices and nightmares that Jack has experienced since childhood have been visions of the Borg Collective, and the voice of the Borg Queen (Alice Krige), weakened after her final confrontation with the older Admiral Kathryn Janeway (Kate Mulgrew). Theyre paid by others? No matter how hard we try to live in the comfort zone and pretend everything is dandy. When Riker and Shelby first met in "The Best of Both Worlds", she was working with Starfleet Tactical on defensive planning for the inevitable attack by the Borg Collective. Its not the 4K that makes UHD pop, its the HDR/Dolby Vision. Something some fans should be reminded of when they call the new shows superficial, immature and not real Star Trek. Ensign Sidney La Forge 10 episodes, 2023 Joseph Lee . You can preorder the final season on Amazon: Blu-ray for $35.43, Steelbook Blu-ray for $37.49, and DVD for $31.38. Picard's Titan Captain Insults Are Really About The TNG Movies What? Ugh why would anyone want 8 hrs non-stop of this garbage? The Big Picture Star Trek: Picard fans eagerly await the final season's. The cantankerous Captain of the USS Titan has whistled his way into our . Interestingly, Geordi reveals that they'd be unable to use the USS Enterprise-E, a loaded statement that puts Captain Worf (Michael Dorn) on the defensive, by stating that whatever happened to the starship wasn't his fault. I actually have upressed and reedited season 3 into in whole movie (8hrs+ long!). What now? But dont touch my stuff, Seven of Nine. In the final version, Shaw said: Its not my ship anymore. I must have blocked that. Picard's Captain Shaw Can Return In Star Trek: Legacy, Says - MSN Deal with the backlash or get the hell off social. Agreed. I loved seeing those characters together again mind you. Geordi explains that, after the Enterprise crashed on Veridian III in Star Trek: Generations, the Prime Directive dictated that all evidence of the starship be removed from the pre-warp planet. Playing Raffi Throughout Star Trek: Picard, I Saw Jonathan Frakes Giving Patrick Stewart a Noogie, Working on Star Trek: Picard Together | LeVar and Mica Burton Interview. Star Trek: Picard's Michelle Hurd says actresses like her can't make rent, Star Trek: Picard named one of the best shows of 2023 so far. At the behest of Picard . stunt driver (1 episode, 2022) Chris Cortez . Or on anything that could, for the 500th time, be explained by there not being enough leeway in the budget, etc. I mean he lost his brother and nephew in a fire of all things. A native of Yorktown, Virginia, he moved to Los Angeles in 2010 to pursue a career in the entertainment industry. Shaw died in the penultimate episode of the season ("Vox") and handed over command of the USS Titan to his first officer, Seven of Nine. Todd Stashwick as Captain Liam Shaw and Jeri Ryan as Seven of Nine in "Imposters" Episode 305, Star Trek: Picard on Paramount+. While its true that creators should expect that nothing they create is going to be meet with universal approval. As for Picard S3, the CGI rendering is a big deal at all. In Shaws death scene, he finally acknowledged his second in command by the name she had chosenSeven of Nine (Jeri Ryan) instead of using her birth name of Annika Hansen, which he insisted she go by aboard his ship. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), 2023 Macmillan | All stories, art, and posts are the copyright of their respective authors. My explanation for the line that could be extremely wrong admittedly: hes regretting deleting all of Rikers music off the ships computer and realizes that she could do the same to his stuff so he says that. The results are a decent, if not slightly soft, looking image. Nemesis was superior to this show,why? In a moment of dark irony, it's revealed that for all her time in Starfleet Tactical, Shelby didn't predict Star Trek: Picard's new Borg attack. They manuvered together to make the Borg insignia? In his final moments, he finally referred to his First Officer Seven of Nine (Jeri Ryan) by her preferred name and transferred command to her. Why cant creatives have the SAME right? But dismissing a disc because its an upscale is based on nothing but ignorance. I have been using TOPAZ VAI for a couple of years now and the result are worth the effort. Shaw's harrowing Borg story tragically set up his Star Trek: Picard death; like the senior officer who saved him aboard the USS Constance, Shaw gives his own life to ensure that Jean-Luc Picard made it to the shuttle. I agree with this, its not nearly as good as the classic shows were, but I still enjoy it! But I like to to read reviews first to verify that its a substantial upgrade. I really hope they announce a new streaming service for the show soon. Shaw's animosity toward Picard was because he was a survivor of the Borg attack on . They arent reference quality but still a big improvement over the 1080p version. #picard3#firstepisode#crusher#laforge#worf#lore#moriarti#titan#riker#son#troi#vadic#changelings#data I read someplace recently that Disney actually stripped the HDR out of some releases, making their UHDs even less worthwhile. On some movies (Dune, for example), its totally stunning, while on others its barely noticeable. Star Trek has seen several shows end this year, but why? Over on Twitter X, Matalas shared Shaws alternate death scene, which you can watch below: Shaws alternate death scene. But again, Im not stopping anyone who just wants to assume that what they are getting with any 4K UHD purchase is a substantial upgrade. 100%. Who played the Orion science vessel captain in Star Treks Those Old Scientists? Odds are he vanity searches and uses blockchain Im blocked by him and literally the only socmed interaction Ive ever had with the dude was thanking him for clarifying a bit of lore someone else asked about. He was Locutus, etc I dont think his final chapter ending with yet another terrible loss wouold have done the story justice. Now for myself it no longer is social acceptable is if they start attacking or name calling you. As the Frontier Day celebrations begin, a nightmarish alliance between two of Starfleet's biggest enemies disturbingly separates the last generation from the next. The whole thing seemed contrived. Titanwill have to wait and see if well be seeing more of him beyond next week. Star Trek: Todd Stashwick on Captain Shaw's Unique "Gen X" Appeal Unpopular opinion about Captain Shaw [No Spoilers] : r/Picard - Reddit But there are *plenty* of 4K UHD sourced from upscaled material. Totally unnecessary to kill a good new character. "I'm gonna go grab a LaCroix," he tells Den of Geek when we catch up with him over Zoom post- Star Trek: Picard season 3. . In fact, by telling me that Im not allowed to have this opinion, youre violating your own standard that youre applying here for a person that unnecessarily and over-defensively blocks people. The third and final season of Star Trek: Picard is now streaming on Paramount+. Killing Shaw was beyond dumb . For example, if you read reviews of the 4K UHD of Heat, many point out the poor color timing and the lackluster HDR, plus other issuesthe 2017 BR is rated better by some. Star Trek: Picard's Todd Stashwick Says Goodbye to Captain Shaw (Exclusive) By Jamie Lovett - April 18, 2023 01:54 pm EDT 1 A lot happened in Star Trek: Picard Season 3, Episode 9, "Vox.". So, even putting aside the actual toxic fans, I can easily see a creator getting tired of seeing criticisms about certain issues they didnt have control over and cant talk about freely, and just putting a hard stop on it. The commanding officer of the USS Titan, which used to be Captain Will Rikers (Jonathan Frakes) ship, Shaw was gruff, unpleasant, sarcastic, and a strict rule followerat first. No one on a social network platform is required to have others opinions shown or listed. He currently writes lists, features, and news articles covering movies, comics, and television. Can you share your process for doing that I would like to try that for some other stuff for sure. I simply take it on a case-by-case basis and read the reviews Bluray.com, HiDef Digest, Digital Bits, plus others. Matalas shared an alternate cut of Shaw's death. By: TrekMovie.com Staff Captain Shaw's Star Trek Picard Alternate Death Scene Revealed By Now you can see an alternate take from that emotional. Dont need super high rez on that size set, even watching from 2 away. Sorry dude, but you dont get to tell me that I cant have this opinion. It's highly unlikely that we'll hear anything about Star Trek: Legacy while the writers and actors continue to strike for fair wages and better working conditions, however, fans certainly shouldn't give up hope. After eight episodes, Star Trek: Picard season 3, episode 9 revealed what was behind Jack's red door - a Borg Cube. The point is, its fine to read reviews to inform your purchasing choices. Captain Shaw was amazing at the first few episodes. Photo Credit: Trae Patton/ Paramount+. Interestingly, the young Borg drones don't attempt to assimilate their older crew mates and instead take the Borg mantra of "resistance is futile" to heart, by killing anyone who attempts to stop them. It would be an upscale so its not really all that exciting to get it in 4K. Captain Liam Shaw (Todd Stashwick) and the rest of Picard's old crew decided to abandon ship, with a running firefight taking place on the way to an emergency shuttle. Honestly? Captain Shaw's Star Trek Picard Alternate Death Scene Revealed By I mustve missed the news. At the end of the dayno one can accuse Star Trek Nemesis of being a good film. Your definition of a good episode must be they bring a truly GREAT character back after 30 years? But that isnt what seems to be the case that I am reading (if I missed any mentions of that, my apologies). Todd Stashwick is thirsty. Huh? Star Trek Picard - Captain Shaw's death scene - YouTube Its good to talk to another videophile who appreciates all this! And as you are probably aware, T2 is panned by many as the worst 4K release ever. Infact most of 4K UHDs are upscaled. You cant have it both ways where you tweet your stuff every day to market your material, but then be a dick and block people who have some critiques on it. Recap/Review: 'Star Trek: Picard' Confronts The Truth In "Imposters" All in all, this was a fledgling 4K UHD attempt with solid HDR application, and not much else to differentiate itself from the Blu-ray. Fans have their right to their opinions on what matters to them and how theyd like the shows to be, but the teams behind the shows arent required to be bombarded with them every day either if they choose they dont want to be. But it turns out Picard had 2 kids. All three seasons of Star Trek: Picard are currently available to stream on Paramount+. It's unclear what this means for alien species whose brains develop at different rates to Humans, but ultimately, every young officer on every starship in the fleet has become a Borg drone. Send him chocolates and all will be forgiven. Released in 1994, Star Trek Generations is best remembered for the cast of Star Trek: The Next Generation making the leap to the big screen and for Picard meeting his . Yep. Rest in peace, Captain Shaw, you beloved a-hole. But Im not sure if what you say about Picard is even true. Head Topics, publish breaking news of all around the world. He gets to be the one who does that, and I think hed probably have it no other way. Star Trek: Picard The Final Season arrives on September 5th on DVD, Blu-ray, and a limited-edition Blu-ray SteelBook. Is this coming to home video, once completed? RELATED: Every Star Trek Ship In Picards Starfleet Museum. No real rush Ive had a UHD player for years, but still havent gotten a proper TV, plus my main one blew out three years ago, so Im watching on the 32 backup. I never said he was prohibited from blocking anyone. It is Star Trek, after all, and he wouldnt be the first character to return from the dead. So we dont not agree(tho I think you knew that). stunt performer (1 episode, 2022) Ilyana Eberhardt . After getting in a few more gleeful digs at Riker and Picard, Shaw escorts them to face the security team, led by none other than Ro F-ing Laren. He is also a trained audio engineer with a degree from the Los Angeles Film School, and manages multiple corporate social media accounts. Well in the end those others are paid by viewers. That was a native 4K remaster and its a super disappointing disc. Ouch! Period. Shaw: Of course it is. The USS Excelsior managed to briefly wrestle control back from the Borg drones, before being destroyed by the other ships when it broke away from the fleet. [via Screenrant], Shaws alternate death scene. But thats about it. So sure, those creators have the right to block (and I totally get that it may be our of critique fatigue as you mention), but if fans subjectively judge that they are abusing that privilege, then of course we as fans have the right to call them out in another forum where fans talk thats all Im saying we have our similar right to call them out on what we perceive as obtuse blocking of fans. And lets be clear with ads going on social platforms, there are many people who do earn their living based on public views and interactions of their social media. Im aware a few people have given a negative review to Fury Roads UHD. Picard Season 3's Tragic Titan Death Changes Star Trek: Legacy - MSN Captain Liam Shaw 10 episodes, 2023 Ashlei Sharpe Chestnut . There are definitely more oranges and splashes of colors on the girls outfits, but this is not a leaps and bounds transfer by any means. The simple fact is they dont owe us a single thing. Heres how you could end this show. Picard's already established that death is a flexible concept, so *shrugs* The idea of de-death via Borg bioengineering would be a remarkable extra layer for Shaw that would allow tons of character exploration. And its not a pimple on the ass of TNG/DS9. Because creatives wouldnt have a job if it wasnt for the fans. The death of Captain Jean-Luc Picard's family in Star Trek Generations was an idea that came from Patrick Stewart himself, and the devastating full extent of Picard's loss was something the actor pushed for during preproduction. We may earn a commission from links on this page. Picard's Captain Shaw Can Return In Star Trek: Legacy, Says Showrunner Warning: Spoilers For Star Trek: Picard Season 3, Episode 9 - "Vox" Star Trek: Picard season 3 showrunner Terry Matalas confirms that Captain Liam Shaw ( Todd Stashwick) can still appear in his proposed spinoff show Star Trek: Legacy. I dont know if thats true but Upscale 4K can still look incredible. Now you can see an alternate take from that emotional scene. Carter, a 21-year-old Black American man, was found dead from a gunshot while handcuffed in the back of a police patrol car . His last scene was a memorable one, but showrunner Terry Matalas just released an alternate version. Watch a Young Keanu Reeves Go to a Teddy Bear Convention. In his final moments, Shaw transfers command of the USS Titan-A to Commander Seven Of Nine (Jeri Ryan), who he finally addresses by her preferred name.